[ad_1]
Black Americans die at a higher rate than white Americans at almost any age.
In 2019, the most recent year for which death data are available, approximately 62,000 such premature deaths, or one in every five African American deaths, occurred.
The age group most affected by inequality was infants. Black babies were more than twice as likely to die before their first birthday as white babies.
General mortality inequality centuries. racist incitement some of the main social determinants of health, such as low levels of Income and generational wealth; healthy access less food, water and public spaces; environmental damage; excessive policing and disproportionate incarceration; and prolonged stress discrimination.
However, the healthcare system also plays a role in this inequality.
Research shows that Black Americans receive less and less quality care for conditions such as: Cancer, heart problems, pneumonia, Pain Management, prenatal and maternal healthand general preventive health. During the pandemic, this racial longevity gap regrow after contraction in recent years.
Some clues to why health care for African Americans are failing can be found in a document written 100 years ago: Flexner Report.
In the early 1900s, the US medical field was in turmoil. Drowning students for short academic terms with scant clinical facilities, medical schools filled the field with unskilled doctors and pocketed tuition fees. Dangerous charlatans and swindlers flourished.
Doctors, led by the American Medical Association (AMA), were pushing for reform. Abraham Flexner, an educator, was selected to conduct a nationwide study of the state of medical schools.
He didn’t like what he saw.
The Flexner Report, published in 1910, devastated the unregulated state of medical education and called for professional standards to produce a force of “fewer and better doctors.”
Flexner recommended raising students’ pre-medical entry requirements and academic requirements. Medical schools should partner with hospitals, invest more in faculty and facilities, and adopt Northern city education models. States should support regulations. Specializations should be expanded. Medicine should be based on science.
The effects were remarkable. As state boards enforced the standards, more than half of medical schools in the US and Canada closed, and the number of practices and physicians fell.
The new rules brought advances to doctors across the country, giving the field a new level of scientific rigor and protection for patients.
But there was also a lesser-known side to the Flexner Report.
Black Americans are already a low experience with the healthcare system. Black patients received separate care; Black medical students were excluded from educational programs; Black doctors lacked the resources for their practice. Delivering the new standards without the tools to implement it, the Flexner report was devastating for Black medicine.
Of the seven Black medical schools in existence at the time, only 2nd – Howard and Meharry – remained for Black applicants who were historically barred from white institutions.
The new requirements for students, particularly higher tuition fees driven by elevated medical school standards, also meant that those who were wealthy and resourced were much more likely to enter than those who were not.
The report recommended that Black doctors should only see Black patients and focus on areas such as hygiene and “dangerous” to specialize in other parts of the profession. Flexner said the white medical field must provide care to Black patients as a moral imperative, but also to prevent them from infecting white people. Integration, seen as medically dangerous, was out of the question.
The effect of this was to narrow the field of medicine in terms of both the total number of doctors and the diversity of race and class in their ranks.
When the report was published, doctors led by the AMA, already organizes to make the area more privileged. Developed under the guidance of the AMA’s education council, the report’s new professional requirements strengthened these efforts under the heading of improvement.
Elite white doctors now faced less competition with doctors offering lower prices or free care. The working class or the poor may exclude those they think the profession degrades to their social status, including women, rural Southerners, immigrants, and Blacks.
And so a vision arose the ideal doctor: A rich white man from a northern city. Control of the medical field was in the hands of these doctors, who had professional and cultural mechanisms to limit others.
To a large extent, the Flexner standards continue to influence American medicine today.
*****
But the medical institution did not follow all the recommendations of the report.
The Flexner Report noted that preventing health problems in the wider community serves the public better than the more profitable business of treating a single patient.
“The overwhelming importance of preventive medicine, sanitation and public health shows that the medical profession in modern life” is not a job to be “exploited by individuals”.
But in the century since then, the AMA and allied groups have mostly defended the interests of their member doctors, often opposing publicly funded programs that could hurt their earnings.
Across the healthcare system, the typically lower priority given to public health disproportionately affects Black Americans.
Lower repayment rates discourage doctors From accepting Medicaid patients. twelve statesdid not expand Medicaid as part of the Affordable Care Act, largely in the South.
Specialists such as plastic surgeons or orthopedists earn more pediatricians and family, public health and preventive doctors – those who deal with heart disease, diabetes, hypertension and other conditions that disproportionately kill Black people.
Because Americans have access to varying levels of care depending on the resources they have, Black doctors say many patients are, in effect, still kept apart.
*****
The transatlantic slave trade began a grueling relationship with Western medicine and a never-corrected health disadvantage for Black Americans, first described by physician and medical historian Dr. It was called the “slave health gap” by W. Michael Byrd.
Born in 1943 in Galveston, Texas, Dr. Byrd grew up hearing the sting of slavery from his great-grandmother, who was freed as a young girl. The disastrous effects of slavery on the health of Blacks were clear. But by the time he was a medical student, those days were long gone—why was he still seeing so many African Americans die?
Dr. Linda A. Clayton had the same question.
His grandfather was also freed from slavery when he was a child. And growing up, she saw blacks struggle with the healthcare system—even those in her own family who could afford to pay for the care. His aunt died at birth. Two siblings with polio were not treated fairly. He died young of cancer after his mother was misdiagnosed.
By 1988, Dr. Byrd and Dr. Clayton had been collecting, publishing and teaching data on Black health inequalities to doctors for 20 years, drawing attention in the news media and before, when they met as faculty members of the Meharry College of Medicine in Nashville. Congress.
In their decades-long partnership and ensuing marriage, the two built on this work and built a story of race and medicine that had never been extensively covered in the United States. said, publishing their findings in a two-volume study,An American Health Dilemma(2000 and 2001, Routledge).
*****
Much has changed since the publication of the Flexner Report.
Racial discrimination is prohibited by law. Medical schools, practices and hospitals are segregated.
In 2008, a former AMA president, Dr. Ronald M. Davis officially apologized to black doctors and patients. Association established minority businesses forum and a national Center for Equality in Health; collaborated with National Medical Association, historically Black medical schools and others in Black health; and created social assistance and scholarships.
However, Dr. Clayton and Dr. They questioned whether the field is working hard enough to change persistent inequalities, Byrd said. And they’re not the only experts wondering.
According to Adam Biggs, an instructor in African-American studies and history at the University of South Carolina at Lancaster, Flexner’s eminent physician figure still reigns. This person is likely to have the resources to bear the tuition and debt; take time and coaching for testing and medical preparation; and years of low-paying education required by an MD.
Evan Hart, an assistant professor of history at Missouri Western State University, has taught courses on race and health. He said medical school education is prohibitively expensive for many Black students.
Earlier this year a AMA article It is estimated that there are 30,000-35,000 fewer Black doctors due to the Flexner Report.
Black people wear makeup today 13 percent Americans, but 5 percent the number of doctors – increased by only two percentage points compared to half a century ago. Inside higher–payment specialties, the gap grows. Doctors less rich backgrounds and other disadvantaged groups are also underrepresented.
This inequality seems to exist real world effects on patients. A study He showed that Black infant mortality was cut in half when a Black doctor provided treatment. Another It showed that Black men more often accept certain preventive measures when seen by Black doctors. Data It showed that more than 60 percent of black medical school enrollees planned to work in underserved communities, compared to less than 30 percent of whites.
The limits of progress are perhaps most evident in the continuing number of Black Americans in poor health who die prematurely. Millions remain chronically uninsured or underinsured.
Dr. According to Clayton, the main problem is that the health system continues to segregate the care of individuals versus the whole, between the private and the public, those with resources and those without.
Medicare and Medicaid during the Civil Rights movement BUT he opposed – partially passed due to advocacy black doctorsextends care to millions of low-income and older Americans. But the AMA’s long war against public programs has contributed to the United States’ position as the only developed nation without universal coverage. When a social safety net is frayed, research demonstrationsIt can hurt Black Americans more, and also expose less privileged members of all races.
Dr. “It’s basically a segregated system within a legally segregated system,” Clayton said.
*****
In February, Dr. Byrd died at a hospital in Nashville at the age of 77 from heart failure. Dr. Clayton was holding her hand.
Before his death, the two doctors had given hours of interviews to The New York Times/The Marshall Project for six months.
Dr. Byrd said he wanted to spread awareness to more American doctors, and to Americans in general, about the Black health crisis where slavery began and continues in an incompletely segregated healthcare system.
Doctors’ work has shown that at no time in the country’s history Blacks’ health has come close to par with whites.
“We’re still waiting,” said Dr. Byrd.
Published in partnership with this article Marshall Project, A nonprofit news organization covering the US criminal justice system. Sign up for newsletteror follow The Marshall Project Facebook or excitement. Anna Flagg is a senior data reporter for the Marshall Project.
[ad_2]
Source link